| Year | All-Stars (Pos.) |
|---|---|
| 2012 | Ryan Cook (P) |
| 2011 | Gio Gonzalez (P) |
| 2010 | Andrew Bailey (P), Trevor Cahill (P) |
| 2009 | Andrew Bailey (P) |
| 2008 | Justin Duchscherer (P) |
| 2007 | Dan Haren (P) |
| 2006 | Barry Zito (P) |
| 2005 | Justin Duchscherer (P) |
| 2004 | Tim Hudson (P), Mark Mulder (P) |
| 2003 | Keith Foulke (P), Ramon Hernandez (C), Barry Zito (P), Mark Mulder (P) |
| 2002 | Barry Zito (P), Miguel Tejada (SS) |
| 2001 | Jason Giambi (1B) |
| 2000 | Jason Giambi (1B), Tim Hudson (P), Jason Isringhausen (P) |
| 1999 | John Jaha (1B) |
| 1998 | Ben Grieve (OF), Art Howe (Coach) |
| 1997 | Mark McGwire (1B) |
| 1996 | Mark McGwire (1B) |
| 1995 | Steve Ontiveros (P), Mark McGwire (1B) |
| 1994 | Ruben Sierra (OF) |
| 1993 | Terry Steinbach (C) |
| 1992 | Jose Canseco (OF), Dennis Eckersley (P), Mark McGwire (1B) |
| 1991 | Harold Baines (OF), Dave Duncan (C/Coach), Dennis Eckersley (P), Dave Henderson (OF), Tommie Reynolds (Coach), Rene Lachemann (Coach), Mark McGwire (1B), Rickey Henderson (OF), Tony LaRussa (Coach/Manager) |
| 1990 | Jose Canseco (OF), Dave Duncan (C/Coach), Dennis Eckersley (P), Bob Welch (P), Dave McKay (Coach), Mark McGwire (1B), Rickey Henderson (OF), Tony LaRussa (Coach/Manager) |
| 1989 | Jose Canseco (OF), Dave Duncan (C/Coach), Art Kusnyer (Coach), Mike Moore (P), Terry Steinbach (C), Dave Stewart (P), Mark McGwire (1B), Tony LaRussa (Coach/Manager) |
| 1988 | Jose Canseco (OF), Dennis Eckersley (P), Carney Lansford (3B), Terry Steinbach (C), Mark McGwire (1B) |
| 1987 | Jay Howell (P), Rene Lachemann (Coach), Mark McGwire (1B), Tony LaRussa (Coach/Manager) |
| 1986 | Jose Canseco (OF) |
| 1985 | Jay Howell (P) |
| 1984 | Bill Caudill (3B), Jackie Moore (Coach), Rickey Henderson (OF) |
| 1983 | Rickey Henderson (OF) |
| 1982 | Art Fowler (Coach), Billy Martin (Manager), Jackie Moore (Coach), Rickey Henderson (OF) |
| 1981 | Tony Armas (OF), Mike Norris (P) |
| 1980 | Rickey Henderson (OF) |
| 1979 | Jeff Newman (C) |
| 1978 | Matt Keough (P) |
| 1977 | Wayne Gross (3B) |
| 1976 | Phil Garner (2B), Rollie Fingers (P) |
| 1975 | Vida Blue (P), Sal Bando (3B), Bert Campaneris (SS), Alvin Dark (Manager), Rollie Fingers (P), Wes Stock (Coach), Joe Rudi (OF), Gene Tenace (C), Claudell Washington (OF), Reggie Jackson (OF) |
| 1974 | Sal Bando (3B), Bert Campaneris (SS), Rollie Fingers (P), Jim Hunter (P), Joe Rudi (OF), Reggie Jackson (OF) |
| 1973 | Sal Bando (3B), Bert Campaneris (SS), Rollie Fingers (P), Jim Hunter (P), Ken Holtzman (P), Dick Williams (Coach/Manager), Reggie Jackson (OF) |
| 1972 | Sal Bando (3B), Bert Campaneris (SS), Jim Hunter (P), Ken Holtzman (P), Dick Williams (Coach/Manager), Joe Rudi (OF), Reggie Jackson (OF) |
| 1971 | Vida Blue (P), Dave Duncan (C/Coach), Reggie Jackson (OF) |
| 1970 | Jim Hunter (P) |
| 1969 | Sal Bando (3B), John Odom (P), Reggie Jackson (OF) |
| 1968 | Bert Campaneris (SS), Rick Monday (OF), John Odom (P) |
| 1967 | Jim Hunter (P) |
| 1966 | Jim Hunter (P) |
| 1965 | John O'Donoghue (P) |
| 1964 | John Wyatt (P) |
| 1963 | Norm Siebern (1B/OF) |
| 1962 | Hank Bauer (Coach), Norm Siebern (1B/OF) |
| 1961 | Dick Howser (SS) |
| 1960 | Bud Daley (P) |
| 1959 | Harry Craft (Coach), Bud Daley (P), Roger Maris (OF) |
| 1958 | Bob Cerv (OF) |
| 1957 | Joe DeMaestri (SS) |
| 1956 | Vic Power (1B), Harry Simpson (1B) |
| 1955 | Jim Finigan (3B), Vic Power (1B) |
| 1954 | Jim Finigan (3B) |
| 1953 | Gus Zernial (OF), Eddie Joost (SS), Eddie Robinson (1B) |
| 1952 | Ferris Fain (1B), Bobby Shantz (P) |
| 1951 | Ferris Fain (1B), Bobby Shantz (P) |
| 1950 | Ferris Fain (1B) |
| 1949 | Lou Brissie (P), Alex Kellner (P), Eddie Joost (SS) |
| 1948 | Joe Coleman (P), Buddy Rosar (C) |
| 1947 | Buddy Rosar (C) |
| 1946 | Sam Chapman (OF), Buddy Rosar (C) |
| 1944 | Frank Hayes (C), Bobo Newsom (P) |
| 1943 | Russell Blackburne (Coach), Dick Siebert (1B) |
| 1942 | Bob Johnson (OF) |
| 1941 | Frank Hayes (C) |
| 1940 | Frank Hayes (C), Bob Johnson (OF) |
| 1939 | Frank Hayes (C), Russell Blackburne (Coach), Bob Johnson (OF) |
| 1938 | Bob Johnson (OF) |
| 1937 | Wally Moses (OF) |
| 1936 | Pinky Higgins (3B) |
| 1935 | Lefty Grove (P), Jimmie Foxx (1B), Bob Johnson (OF) |
| 1934 | Lefty Grove (P), Jimmie Foxx (1B), Pinky Higgins (3B) |
| 1933 | Lefty Grove (P), Jimmie Foxx (1B), Connie Mack (Manager) |
