| Year | Players |
|---|---|
| 2007 | Bobby Jenks (P) |
| 2006 | Paul Konerko (1B), Jim Thome (OF), Jose Contreras (P), Jermaine Dye (OF), Mark Buehrle (P), Bobby Jenks (P), @A.J. Pierzynski (C) |
| 2005 | #Mark Buehrle (P), Jon Garland (P), Paul Konerko (1B), @Scott Podsednik (OF) |
| 2004 | Esteban Loaiza (P) |
| 2003 | #Esteban Loaiza (P), Magglio Ordonez (OF), Carl Everett (OF) |
| 2002 | Mark Buehrle (P), Paul Konerko (1B) |
| 2001 | Magglio Ordonez (OF) |
| 2000 | James Baldwin (P), Ray Durham (2B), Magglio Ordonez (OF) |
| 1999 | Magglio Ordonez (OF) |
| 1998 | Ray Durham (2B) |
| 1997 | #*Frank Thomas (1B), Albert Belle (OF) |
| 1996 | #*Frank Thomas (1B), Roberto Hernandez (P) |
| 1995 | #Frank Thomas (1B) |
| 1994 | #Frank Thomas (1B), Wilson Alvarez (P), Jason Bere (P) |
| 1993 | Jack McDowell (P), Frank Thomas (1B) |
| 1992 | Jack McDowell (P), Robin Ventura (3B) |
| 1991 | Carlton Fisk (C), Ozzie Guillen (SS), Jack McDowell (P) |
| 1990 | Ozzie Guillen (SS), Bobby Thigpen (P) |
| 1989 | #Harold Baines (DH) |
| 1988 | *Ozzie Guillen (SS). |
| 1987 | Harold Baines (OF) |
| 1986 | Harold Baines (OF) |
| 1985 | #Carlton Fisk (C), Harold Baines (OF) |
| 1984 | Richard Dotson (P) |
| 1983 | Ron Kittle (OF) |
| 1982 | #Carlton Fisk (C) |
| 1981 | #Carlton Fisk (C), Britt Burns (P) |
| 1980 | Ed Farmer (P) |
| 1979 | Chet Lemon (OF) |
| 1978 | Chet Lemon (OF) |
| 1977 | #Richie Zisk (OF) |
| 1976 | Rich Gossage (P) |
| 1975 | Bucky Dent (SS), Rich Gossage (P), Jim Kaat (P), Jorge Orta (2B) |
| 1974 | #Dick Allen (1B), Wilbur Wood (P), *Ed Herrmann (C). |
| 1973 | #Dick Allen (1B), Pat Kelly (OF). Kelly replaced Allen due to injury |
| 1972 | #Dick Allen (1B), Carlos May (OF), Wilbur Wood (P) |
| 1971 | Bill Melton (3B) |
| 1970 | #Luis Aparicio (SS) |
| 1969 | Carlos May (OF) |
| 1968 | Tommy John (P), Duane Josephson (C) |
| 1967 | Tommie Agee (OF), Ken Berry (OF), Joel Horlen (P), Gary Peters (P) |
| 1966 | Tommie Agee (OF) |
| 1965 | Eddie Fisher (P), Bill Skowron (1B) |
| 1964 | Gary Peters (P), Juan Pizarro (P) |
| 1963 | Nellie Fox (2B), Juan Pizarro (P) |
| 1962 | Luis Aparicio (SS), Jim Landis (OF) |
| 1961 | Nellie Fox (2B), Billy Pierce (P), Luis Aparicio (SS), Ray Herbert (P), Roy Sievers (1B) |
| 1960 | #Minnie Minoso (OF), Luis Aparicio (SS), Nellie Fox (2B), Sherm Lollar (C), Gerry Staley (P), Early Wynn (P), Al Smith (OF) |
| 1959 | #Luis Aparicio (SS), #Nellie Fox (2B), #Early Wynn (P), Sherm Lollar (C), Billy Pierce (P) |
| 1958 | #Luis Aparicio (SS), #Nellie Fox (2B), Sherm Lollar (C), Billy Pierce (P), Early Wynn (P) |
| 1957 | #Nellie Fox (2B), Minnie Minoso (OF), Billy Pierce (P) |
| 1956 | #Nellie Fox (2B), #Billy Pierce (P), Sherm Lollar (C), Jim Wilson (P) |
| 1955 | #Nellie Fox (2B), #Billy Pierce (P), Chico Carrasquel (SS), Sherm Lollar (C), Dick Donovan (P) |
| 1954 | #Minnie Minoso (OF), #Chico Carrasquel (SS), Sandy Consuegra (P), Nellie Fox (2B), Bob Keegan (P), Sherm Lollar (C), Virgil Trucks (P), *George Kell (3B), *Ferris Fain (1B) |
| 1953 | #Chico Carrasquel (SS), #Billy Pierce (P), Nellie Fox (2B), Ferris Fain (1B), Minnie Minoso (OF) |
| 1952 | #Eddie Robinson (1B), Nellie Fox (2B), Minnie Minoso (OF) |
| 1951 | #Chico Carrasquel (SS), #Nellie Fox (2B), Jim Busby (OF), Randy Gumpert (P), Minnie Minoso (OF), Eddie Robinson (1B) |
| 1950 | Rae Scarborough (P) |
| 1949 | #Cass Michaels (2B) |
| 1948 | Joe Haynes (P) |
| 1947 | Luke Appling (SS), Rudy York (1B) |
| 1946 | Luke Appling (SS) |
| 1944 | #Thurman Tucker (OF), Orval Grove (P) |
| 1943 | Luke Appling (SS) |
| 1942 | Edgar Smith (P) |
| 1941 | Luke Appling (SS), Thornton Lee (P), Edgar Smith (P) |
| 1940 | #Luke Appling (SS) |
| 1939 | Luke Appling (SS), Ted Lyons (P) |
| 1938 | #Mike Kreevich (OF) |
| 1937 | Luke Sewell (C), *Monty Stratton (P). |
| 1936 | #Luke Appling (SS), #Rip Radcliff (OF), Vern Kennedy (P) |
| 1935 | #Al Simmons (OF) |
| 1934 | #Al Simmons (OF), Jimmy Dykes (3B) |
| 1933 | #Al Simmons (OF), Jimmy Dykes (3B) |
| #Selected as a starter | @Online fan balloting winner | *Injured, did not play | |
